Conservative Intelligence

Conservative Intelligence

Not Access. Not Lobbying. Just Intelligence.

Intelligence Letter

This area is a password-protected resource.  Members of Conservative Intelligence will receive short, easy-to-read newsletters written by the Conservative Home team. The letter will provide expert analysis of the key policies, personalities and strategic choices of the Conservative Party.

Below is an example of one of our Weekly Intelligence Letters.  

CAMERON’S EURO-REBELLION WASN’T A ONE-OFF

Most MPs want to be Ministers.  For older ones, office (or the prospect of it) has come and gone; for new ones,  the possibility is still there.  This helps to explain the conventional Commons wisdom that new intakes are always the least rebellious.  Last Monday, this viewpoint was turned on its head: almost 50 members of the 2010 intake refused to back the Government in the lobbies on the EU referendum vote.

This has been explained by MP concerns about not being selected by Euro-sceptic local Conservative Associations when the reduction of Commons seats is brought into effect.  By resentment with David Cameron over policy and personnel.  And by responsiveness to local opinion: while the EU isn’t a voter priority, those who feel strongly about it are often vocal and active.

That last reason is particularly powerful, but should be understood as part of a culture change that is taking place among Tory MPs.  A generation ago, most saw the role as work, but not as a job: most had outside interests, and thus worked outside the Commons as well as within it.  But since then, that idea of what an MP is has changed, as the vote share of the main political parties has declined and voter demands have risen.

The expenses scandal has served only to accelerate this process: part of the response to it was a toughening-up of rules on the declaration of outside interests.  In the competitive world of modern constituency politics, no-one wants to be labelled a part-time MP.  During the last Parliament, David Cameron’s experiment with open primaries was a nod to today’s voters seeing themselves as masters, not servants.

The consequence is a new generation of MPs that, tugged between the Government Whips on the one hand and their voters on the other, will usually put local views first: after all, the chance of losing one’s seat is more terrifying than that of not being made a Minister.  It is no coincidence that the two new MPs selected by full open primaries, Caroline Dinenage and Sarah Wollaston, voted against the Government on Monday.

In Opposition, Cameron attempted to exploit the anti-politics mood not only with open primaries but by first setting up a special A-list of candidates and by later appealing for future MPs with no background in the party at all.  The combined consequence of this short-term political experiment and longer-term cultural change is a headache for his own whips.  The old appeals to loyalty simply count for less.

They had force in a Commons collectively shaped by the militarising experience of World War Two: indeed, many of the whips of an older generation had been wartime officers.  But they have less in a new century in which hierarchy and deference are strangers.  MPs who have worked in business, where working structures are often flat and women have senior positions, often see the whips’ ways as part of a bygone age.

The logic of these changes is for executive and legislature to go their separate ways: for MPs be become full-time legislators and for Ministers to be drawn from outside Parliament altogether.  But politics isn’t a rationalist business, and the present uneasy accommodation looks set to continue.  It is aided by Labour seats being different from Tory ones: voters in them are less active (though they provide more casework).

In short, the trend for MPs as local champions rather than distant representatives looks set to continue: no wonder this is already the most rebellious Parliament on the Government side since the war.  And although the Europe issue is especially toxic for the Conservatives, the speed at which Government proposals for forestry and free milk were dropped is a reminder that rebelliousness can flare up at any time.

Cameron is going to have to take a long hard look at the relationship between the Whips and his backbenches.  There are no easy answers to managing the tension, which in most respects is a healthy one, between government and constituents, but Number Ten must be asking itself if there is a proper plan for helping the new Tory intake in particular to juggle their role as MPs – one that is becoming more difficult and demanding.

By Paul Goodman

To receive these weekly, or read past letters and profiles, sign up for membership.

Basic Membership

  • Access to the online members area for profiles of Cameron’s closest team
  • Access to an archive of all our IntelligenceLetters and briefings.
  • The weekly Intelligence Letter give you the must have information on the Conservative Party for that week.
  • Priority booking to all of our events and access to the events we host at the Spring Forum and Conservative Party Conference.

Login

From the Conservative Intelligence member's site

The Past Destroyed Miller – Might Her Replacement Be The Conservative Party’s Future?

The Maria Miller scandal was rooted firmly in the past – the sins of the old expenses system still haunt Parliament, even years after it was abolished. The reshuffle following her resignation, though, was entirely about the future. First, there’s the short-term future of the Coalition government. Even before the expenses scandal reignited, DCMS was […]

The Crucial Importance Of Graham Brady

Four days after the 2010 general election of that year, the 1922 Committee of Conservative MPs met in the Commons.  David Cameron persuaded it to support in principle the formation of a coalition with the Liberal Democrats, arguing that the alternative was a Labour-LibDem Government that would force electoral reform through the Commons without a […]

Cameron The Pragmatist Pushes His Rivals Towards The Margins Of Politics

A point sometimes arrives, in a game of bridge, when it becomes clear that the cards are falling right for a player. Almost everything attempted by that player comes off, not only because of his or her own skill, but because of the distribution of cards in his or her opponents’ hands, and the inability […]

Osborne Will Be Pleased With The Revolution In His Fortunes

What a difference two years makes. At this point in 2012, George Osborne’s budget was under fire from all sides, and the Chancellor himself found both his competence and career being called into question. That must now seem like a bad dream, as he reviews the 2014 headlines hailing his policy radicalism and political nous. […]

The Boris Problem – And How To Minimise It.

Some readers of this newsletter will have followed this week’s headlines about Tory tensions involving George Osborne, Michael Gove and Boris Johnson.  They therefore won’t be familiar with the detail – but will have picked up a clear impression: namely, that the flow of stories about possible future Conservative leaders has done nothing to help […]

Behind Confusion About Immigration Lies Deeper Confusion About What It Means To Be British

At Prime Minister’s Questions on Wednesday, not a single MP ventured to ask about immigration. Downing Street at this point stood accused of suppressing a report on the subject, but no one saw advantage in voicing the accusation. The report has since been published. It implies that Theresa May, the Home Secretary, was exaggerating when […]

Merkel’s Visit Hasn’t Helped Cameron – But Has It Harmed Him?

David Cameron was full of warm words and smiles yesterday as Angela Merkel visited Westminster. As one German reporter suggested, the red carpet treatment was befitting a “Queen of Europe” – and the Prime Minister certainly pulled out every stop short of a trumpet fanfare and artillery salute. The generous hospitality did not exactly pay […]

Cameron’s Time Bomb For Scotland’s Referendum

As Brian Monteith pointed out on ConservativeHome last week, Scotland is “now the third most economically successful region of the UK (after London and the South East), and has been third or fourth for the last thirty years”.  Furthermore, complaints about England subsidising Scotland may be inaccurate: the SNP claims that the flow of money […]

Wythenshawe Will Make It Even Harder For Cameron To Persuade His Own MPs To Follow Him

David Cameron says he will listen to the “signal” sent by voters in the Wythenshawe and Sale East by-election. Here are two of the things he will hear. The first point people in Wythenshawe are making is that unlike the Lib Dems (who lost their deposit), Labour is indestructible. Or to put it another way: […]

Next Week’s By-Election Has Some Tough Messages For Tories

No-one in Westminster is under the illusion that a by-election is an accurate barometer of national opinion. Disproportionate amounts of money are thrown at the campaign, headline-hungry newspapers give gaffes a prominence they might never receive in a General Election, and everyone’s on the lookout for upsets or shocks. Freakish as they may be, they […]

© 2014 Conservative Intelligence | About | Contact Conservative Intelligence | Register | Website by Tjugo Tjugo